Paleo Italian-Marinated Steak & Mushrooms

Paleo Italian-Marinated Steak & Mushrooms


Are you a steak purist?

Do you cringe at the thought of dumping steak sauce all over a perfectly grilled grass-fed steak?

This marinated steak and mushrooms recipe is so flavorful no one will even think of reaching for the steak sauce!

A thick, juicy steak, still sizzling from the grill, is the perfect summer meal.

My husband thinks it’s almost blasphemous to put sauce on a good steak. In my younger and woefully naive years, I used to love a certain famous brand of steak sauce. Living with a master barbecue chef means I no longer commit such grievous steak sins. He has shown me the error of my ways!

Paleo Italian-Marinated Steak & Mushrooms

So how can you get a flavorful, juicy steak without dousing it in the sauce?


Marinating is the perfect way to infuse flavors and moisture into your beautiful cut of grass-fed beef steak. A vinegar-based marinade will also help tenderize your meat.

Throw in some whole baby bella mushrooms (or your favorite mushroom) and you’ll have flavorful grilled Italian-marinated steak and mushrooms that will satisfy any hearty appetite.

My husband, the grill master, is also my taste-tester when developing recipes. He is hard to please, so if he says anything more than “it’s good”, I really get excited.

His reaction to this recipe about bowled me over. He took one bite, and with big eyes, he said, “You can marinate steak like this any time you want!”

Nailed it.

Marinate all the things.

Don’t limit yourself to beef steaks!

Juicy chicken breasts, crispy-skinned duck, even venison will all be enhanced by a soak in this easy marinade.

Try adding other veggies too, such as onions, peppers, asparagus, or even brussels sprouts. You might want to cook some vegetables in a skillet rather than the grill, but they will still be amazingly delicious.

Will you try this easy paleo marinated steak and mushrooms at your next cookout?

Paleo Italian-Marinated Steak & Mushrooms
This marinated steak and mushrooms recipe is so flavorful no one will even think of reaching for the steak sauce!
    Servings2 to 3 people
    Prep Time5 minutes
    Passive Time3 hours
    • 2pounds steak, cut of choice
    • 8 ounces whole baby bella mushrooms
    • 1cup wild mushroom Italian salad dressing
    • 4 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce
    • 1/2 to 1teaspoon Wildly Organic Himalayan Pink Saltto taste
    1. In a zipper bag large enough to hold your steak, combine salad dressing, Worcestershire sauce and salt.
    2. Add steak and mushrooms.
    3. Seal the bag and gently shake to coat the steak and mushrooms well.
    4. Refrigerate for at least 3 hours, flipping the bag over once or twice.
    5. Remove steak and mushrooms from marinade.
    6. Put mushrooms on a skewer for grilling (they'll only need a few minutes).
    7. Grill steak to desired doneness, adding the mushroom skewer during the last 5 to 8 minutes of grilling time
    8. Turn mushrooms while grilling for even cooking.
    9. Once the steak is done, remove it from the heat and allow it to rest for at least 5 minutes before cutting.

    The post Paleo Italian-Marinated Steak & Mushrooms appeared first on Wildly Organic.

    Previous article How To Make Milk Kefir + A Yummy Kefir Smoothie Recipe!

    Wildly Organic is an independent source for wholesome, organic foods and natural, raw foods and ingredients, the building blocks of a healthy life.